The Brothers Karamazov
Fyodor Dostoevsky
In a provincial town, a depraved old father who raised none of his sons is murdered, and every one of those sons has a reason to hate him.
The Brothers Karamazov is Fyodor Dostoevsky's final novel, serialised in 1879–1880. The wealthy, dissolute landowner Fyodor Pavlovich Karamazov has three sons: passionate, debt-ridden Dmitri; brilliant, sceptical Ivan; and kind-hearted Alyosha, raised in a monastery. There is also the servant Smerdyakov, rumoured to be the father's illegitimate son. As father and Dmitri clash over an inheritance and the same woman, Grushenka, the father is murdered one night. Inside a murder story, the novel carries on one of world literature's great debates about God, free will, guilt and conscience.
Fyodor Pavlovich Karamazov is a joking, lying, pleasure-seeking man who never cared for the sons of his two marriages and left them to be raised by others. Years later the sons gather in the town. The eldest, Dmitri, a former officer from the first marriage, believes his father is withholding his inheritance from his mother. The middle son, Ivan, is a sharp-minded sceptic whose articles appear in journals. The youngest, Alyosha, is a novice at the town's monastery under the revered Elder Zosima.
To settle the inheritance dispute, a family meeting is held at the monastery in Zosima's presence. Fyodor Pavlovich deliberately plays the buffoon, and the meeting ends in scandal. Zosima, to everyone's surprise, bows to the ground before Dmitri, as if he foresees the great suffering awaiting him. Dmitri's trouble is not only money: he and his father are in love with the same woman, the town's beautiful, proud Grushenka. He has also already spent three thousand roubles that he owes his fiancée, Katerina Ivanovna. One night he bursts into his father's house, beats him and shouts that he will kill him one day.
Meanwhile, in a tavern, Ivan pours out his heart to Alyosha. He cannot accept the suffering of innocent children and respectfully returns his ticket to such a world. Then he tells a prose poem he has written, The Grand Inquisitor: Christ returns to sixteenth-century Seville and is arrested by an aged cardinal, who tells him he burdened humanity with a freedom it cannot bear. It is the most famous chapter in the novel. Soon afterwards Zosima passes away, and the unexpectedly rapid decay of his body shakes Alyosha's faith.
Ivan's idea that if there is no God, everything is permitted takes a different shape in the mind of his admirer Smerdyakov, the epileptic servant who cooks in the father's house and whom everyone looks down on. One morning Ivan leaves town for Moscow. Dmitri, desperate for money to repay Katerina and run away with Grushenka, finds none. That night, with a brass pestle in his hand, he enters his father's garden and stands before the window. The narrative falls silent at that very moment.
Fleeing the garden that night, Dmitri strikes down the old servant Grigory, who tries to stop him, with the pestle. Learning that Grushenka has gone to a nearby village to meet her former lover, he follows her, spends wildly through the night, and finally hears her confess her love. At that moment the police arrive; he is arrested for murdering his father and stealing the three thousand roubles. Dmitri protests his innocence, but all the evidence is against him.
Ivan visits Smerdyakov three times. On the last visit, Smerdyakov confesses that he faked an epileptic fit, killed the father himself and took the money, and he counts Ivan as his accomplice: Ivan left the house and taught him that everything is permitted. Feverish, Ivan has a hallucinated conversation with the devil; that same night Smerdyakov hangs himself. At the trial Ivan's testimony is dismissed as raving, a letter produced by Katerina Ivanovna sinks Dmitri, and he is sentenced to twenty years of penal servitude in Siberia. In the epilogue, as a plan to help Dmitri escape to America takes shape, the novel ends at young Ilyusha's funeral, where Alyosha urges the boys never to forget this day and one another.
The Brothers Karamazov is both a gripping murder novel and a great book of ideas. Between passionate quarrels, midnight flights, a courtroom drama and shattering confessions, readers find themselves weighing the deepest questions. Figures from Einstein and Wittgenstein to Kafka and Murakami have expressed their admiration for it.
Dostoevsky passed away about four months after finishing it, so the book is often read as a kind of testament. It is long and crowded, but every character is a world of their own; Ivan and Alyosha's conversation in the tavern in particular is something readers return to throughout their lives.
For: Readers unafraid of big questions, those who have read Crime and Punishment and want more, anyone who enjoys thinking about faith and morality, and readers ready to give time to a long novel.
Fyodor Dostoevsky
Updated: 10 November 2026